The graphic pictures shocked the court room and the jury. Some photos showed a close up of Libby's slashed throat and bloody face. The jury was clearly uncomfortable with seeing the images and there were audible gasps in the courtroom. The families of Libby and Abby were also in the gallery crying.

The second week of the trial of a man accused of killing two Delphi teenagers in 2017 included graphic photos of the murder scene being introduced as exhibits. Carroll County prosecutor Nick McLeland brought two investigators to the stand in the Monday morning session.